Wednesday, November 11, 2015

[Blog Post #5] Vocabulary and Discussion Questions

1. Vocabularies

Decriminalization : Decriminalization or decriminalization is the abolition of criminal penalties in relation to certain acts, perhaps retroactively, though perhaps regulated permits or fines might still apply (for contrast, see: legalization). The reverse process is criminalization. Decriminalization reflects changing social and moral views. A society may come to the view that an act is not harmful, should no longer be criminalized, or is otherwise not a matter to be addressed by the criminal justice system.
Prostitution : Prostitution is the business or practice of engaging in sexual relations in exchange for payment or some other benefit. Prostitution is sometimes described as commercial sex.
Hooker Hill: Hooker Hill is a street in the Itaewon-dong Precinct of Seoul Yongsan-gu, where many brothels are located. It is also known as ‘red-light district’. Although it has a reputation for only American servicemen visiting, this area is well-known among men from other countries, including Middle Easterners and Africans. Furthermore, because South Korea is not widely socially accepting of homosexuals, there is an underground gay area in this district as well.
Mamasan: A "mama-san", or "mamasan" is usually a woman in a position of authority, especially one in charge of a geisha house or bar or nightclub in Japan and East Asia.
Juice: The term “juice” that is used in military camp town bars refer to what the sex workers have to sell to soldiers. Along with the real juice, they also give minor sexual services for a certain amount of time; based on the price of the juice. The prices of the juice goes up if the soldier wants more time together with the sex workers. Bar owners put certain limits of money sex workers have to earn, and if the sex workers don’t meet the quota, bar owners force them to sell sex to satisfy the demand.
VISA E-6-2(Art and Entertainer VISA) : Art and Entertainer VISA is for music, art, and literature for earning money. The top limit length of its visit is 2 years. It is somewhat known as the "prostitute visa" because many are hired as "singers", "dancers", etc only to end up performing sexual services at room salons and other shady establishments
⇨ Military camp side town(Gi-Ji-Chon) : a village formed around the foreign military base
 

2. Discussion Questions

What are some of the stereotypes that you have on sex workers? How did you obtain these stereotypes?

⇨ Were you able to learn something new about this subculture group from our research findings? Did it change the stereotypes that you had of them? 

⇨ How would you react if your spouse confessed to you that he or she was once a sex worker? How about when a family member told you the same thing?

Amnesty international declared decriminalization of sex work to protect sex workers officially. What is your opinion on this decision?
(There is something called sex volunteering for disabled. It started when the notion that 'disabled people also have sexual rights' got popular. Are you for or against this kind of volunteering?)


⇨ What do think makes people to have stereotypes against this subculture group?

Friday, October 23, 2015

[Blog Post #4] Interview Synopsis

1) Interview #1: 'A' _ By Hye-Jin Woo

‘A’ is a female Korean sex worker who has her own bar called ‘N’(initial) in Itaewon ‘Hooker Hill’. She has been working in the sex business for more than 10 years and she opened her own bar 2 years ago. This interview was carried out inside her bar in Itaewon on October 13th, 2015.

ABOUT HER BACKGROUND
She is 41 years old and is from Donghae, Gangwon Province. She started working in this business about 10 years ago for financial reasons, and now has her own bar in Itaewon ‘Hooker Hill’. She has one brother and is currently living by herself near her bar. Even though she had never lived in another country, her English is very fluent (close to that of a native speaker's) because her main customers are foreigners in Itaewon. She watches American TV shows and reads English magazines everyday in order to learn English. ‘A’ is working alone in the bar she owns, because according to her, she is not good at handling the stress that comes from working with other people. She used to have another girl in the bar, but she fired her after a couple of months.

ABOUT SEX BUSINESS IN ITAEWON ‘HOOKER HILL’
The place where her bar ‘N’ is located is called ‘Hooker Hill’. The reason people call the place this name is because there are a lot of sex shops on this street which is also kind of a hill. According to ‘A’, most of the bars (sex shops) are owned by Koreans, but it’s the foreigners-sometimes transgendered foreigners- that work here as sex workers. The customers of these bars are mainly American soldiers or foreign men who are currently residing in Itaewon. Sometimes Korean men come to the bars, but they don’t really let Korean customers in because they could be policemen. They have their own CCTV inside their bars so that they can open it whenever a foreigner approaches. They usually keep their doors closed at all times and do not open it for Korean men.

ABOUT HER LIFE AS A SEX WORKER
‘A’ says that she makes good money with her business, and is satisfied with her job. When asked about the difficulties at work, she answered that dealing with a ‘drunken asshole’ is something that she hates the most. However, she says that there is always something that you can learn from a person, and from a drunken asshole, she can learn how to not behave like an asshole. Her main job is understanding the customers and giving them what they want. In order to do that, she needs to be smart so she reads a lot of books and always tries hard to learn a new language. Although there are a lot of sex shops on the street, she doesn’t make friends with these sex workers because they are just her rivals who are competing against her for customers.

ABOUT THE STEREOTYPES AGAINST ‘SEX WORKERS’
‘A’ was aware of the stereotypes that people have against sex workers, but she didn’t really care about it. Of course sometimes her customers look down on her because of what she does and how she dresses, but she thinks that it’s a natural thing for humans to have stereotypes and prejudices against one another. She asked me whether people have prejudices against the president of this country because she is the daughter of Park Jung-Hee (also a former president), and whether they have prejudice against me because I am an SNU student. She says that people having prejudices and stereotypes are something that you cannot help with, so the important thing is to stay strong and just be confident with what you do.

ABOUT HER BELIEFS
Throughout the interview, ‘A’ mentioned a lot about her beliefs. She is a devout Christian and kept telling me that I should believe in god as well. She says that many of her customers are unhappy people who feel that their lives are meaningless. It doesn’t matter whether they are rich or good looking, they are all miserable because they don’t believe in anything. They all come to Hooker Hill for pleasure, but this pleasure is something that does not last long, and she pities them for being so ignorant of this fact. At the end of the interview, ‘A’ repeatedly told me to let go of all the stereotypes that I had against what she does for a living, and remember her only as a devoted Christian. 


2) Interview #2: 'B' _ By So-Hyun Lee

‘B’ is a counselor who works in ‘Durebang’, a center for assisting Korean and migrant women who are forced to work in military camp town prostitution. We conducted this interview in the center’s counseling room, in October 22nd, 2015.

ABOUT THE JOB
She has been working in this area for 3 years. She first started this job just as a social worker, but she quickly grew interest thanks to her background in hometown Yang-ju, where camp towns existed. What she does is to first out reach for women who need help through much advertising and help sex workers with lawsuits and aiding medical charges. The hardships she face most is confronting policies related to expired VISAs, or other laws because prostitution has been banned since 2004. One case she had trouble with was when a client suicided because the police kept questioning her about her illegally trying to remain in Korea.

ABOUT THE SEX INDUSTRY
She thinks the sex industry should not be legalized nor disclosed to the public because of Korean’s tendency to put customers in priority. She thinks that if the law becomes legalized, culture will only worsen the working environment and put prostitutes in greater danger. She also mentioned that sex workers will not register for the unemployment insurance in fear of labels from the record, looking from Germany’s case. However, compared to Japan, she says Korean sex workers’ human rights are way more guaranteed.

ABOUT SEX WORKERS & STEREOTYPES
First of all, she says that foreign sex workers don’t know about the labels put upon them nor feel discriminated because they rarely meet Koreans due to lack of free time outside. Whereas there is one big stereotype that makes all the troubles; people think these sex workers came to Korea to work voluntarily as a prostitute. Actually, they are mostly deceived and blackmailed economically to work as a prostitute. The bias leads to passing responsibility to victims and also obstruction of interest in the situation. She thinks that this bias comes from lack of stories and information about these women and feels that public attention is needed to eliminate it.

OTHER INFORMATION
She told us about the system how Philippine women come to Korea deceived that they will be singing in bars. They join an agency where they are guaranteed a certain salary, but when the singers are sold to bars in Korea, the owner demands profit limits to repay singers’ ransoms and when they don’t satisfy the limits, they are forced into prostitution and prohibited to go out. Also, she mentioned that women who luckily escape the bars usually go to factories regardless of the equally hard work due to the lack of job spaces in the Philippines. Lastly, she said that there are very few unique cases where sex workers eventually marry an American soldier and remain in Korea.


3)  Interview #3: ‘C’ _ By Seong-Yoon Park 

‘C’ was a sex worker who came from Phillippines with VISA E6 for being a singer. However, her entertainment manager deceived her and she had to work in Dong-Doo-Cheon since 2007 as a sex worker. 

ABOUT HER BACKGROUND 

She thought she could earn money and could support her family. However, she could know that her job was not just a singing after the first day. She had to work for club and customers with sexsual behavior. She was dispirited but she had no choice because of her family in Phillipines. She and other three girls worked every night and could not take a rest. She had to sat side by side a customer and gratify him because he payed for her time by buying a ‘juice’. One night she was alomost raped by one customer. She said that situation to boss, but the boss(‘mamasan’) said it was also a part of a job. She determined to quit a job and fled on September 2007.

ABOUT THE SEX INDUSTRIES 

She said it is unjust that saddling a whole responsibility to sex worker because it is not her ‘choice’ but ‘inevitable choice’. Many people saw sex working is just their choice for money, so it is OK to treat them with sexual behavior. However, she said she was deceived by manager and seeking a job even in small factory was very hard for ‘foreign woman’. 

ABOUT STREOTYPES 

She said she could not recognize stereotypes because she was confined in the ‘home’ all day. However, she said it is obvious misunderstanding that foreign sex workers chose selling their sex as a job. Most of them didn’t know what they would do before entered in Korea. They came with VISA E-6 for being an entertainer. They were selected by entertainment agency in their country, and that agency made a contract with Korean agency. Foreign women prepared sample video, took an audition, and came as a ‘singer’. However, the club which was their work place treated them as a ‘Juice girl’. Buying a juice is same as buying a time of woman. If the customer pay more, she had to spend the night together. 

OTHER INFORMATION 


Foreign sex work industry is somewhat different from Korea. Their workplace is like a pub or bar and they don’t have to sell their sex officially. Most of their customers are US Army, and sometimes they fall in love. Of course, period of love is short and most of boyfriends leaved to America. Sex work women also return to their country after about 2-3 years. 


Wednesday, October 14, 2015

[Blog Post #3] More Articles & Videos

[Blog Post #3] More Articles & Videos


1. CNN News Clip: Living in the nightmare of Korea's 'juicy bars'

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ao1QWX6yCs



  A Filipino woman who was held against her will in a ‘juicy bar’ located near the U.S. Military base in Seoul managed to escape. She initially came to Korea to become a singer, but she was forced to work in a bar where she was sexually exploited. This is a form of human trafficking but the South Korean Ministry of Justice says that these incidents are hard to detect.  


2. The Korea Herald Article : Sex trade businesses caught by police nearly triple in 2 years


(http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20150828000949)

  This article shows the increasing situation of the prostitution in Korea because of the various reasons such as mobile messenger and increasing tourism. Considering the prostitution is illegal in Korea, we can presume it is under-calculated. Of course there is no exact number of foreign women, but a lot of foreign women especially who have to earn money would account high ratio. 

3. The Korea Herald Article : Korean dream shattered by lies, sex trade coercion 




  Many people place the responsibility on women about the prostitution especially for foreign women because they think it is of their own choice just for a money. However, this article shows the social reason such as deceiving or forcing foreign women to do sexual acts. This indicates the need of macroscopic perspective when we search the present condition of the foreign sex worker.


4. Korea times news article: Outside US bases, former bar workers fight sex trafficking





 This article is about stories of how many Filipino women become sex workers, deceived by Korean employers when signing the contract. Most women aren’t explained about how they will work in Korea, and are forced to be a prostitute. If they defy, they are blackmailed or sent away; which is why they can’t quit either.

Sunday, October 4, 2015

[Blog Post #2] Interview Questions

1. Questions for the social worker


These interview questions are specially made for the social worker of a support group for former foreign sex workers in Korea.

 
As we have previously informed you, our group is conducting a research on ‘sex workers, and their stereotypes in Korea’ for a class project. Your interview will help us conduct our research in so many ways.
 
(A) About the job
1. When did you start working at this center for former foreign sex workers in Korea? Was there a particular reason why you came to work for them? If you do, please share it with us.
2. What kind of work does the center do for former sex workers? What is the significance of this work?
3. Are there obstacles in your job? If so, what are they?
4. Is there a particularly memorable client that comes into your mind? If so, who is that person?
 
(B) About sex industry
1. We are aware that there is an ongoing debate in Korea about legalizing sex industry. What is your opinion on this matter? Is there a reason why you think like this?
2. Do you think there is a difference between sex industries in Korea and other countries? If so, what is the difference?
 
(C) About sex workers stereotypes
1. Do you believe that sex workers are stereotyped, especially in Korea? If so, what made you think that way? Also, how are they stereotyped?
2. Do you believe that former sex workers are discriminated against in real life because of these stereotypes? If so, how are they discriminated against specifically?
3. What do you think is the reason that people have stereotypes about them? (Is it because of the negative media coverage on sex workers?)
4. Do you think we should eliminate these kinds of stereotypes? If so, how?
 
(D) Wrap up question
1. Is there anything more you’d like others to know about sex workers or sex industry?
 
Once again, thank you for your time. 


2. Questions for the former sex worker


These interview questions are for the  foreign sex workers in Korea.


 As we previously informed you, our group is conducting a research on foreign sex workers in Korea for a class project. We thank you for agreeing to participate in this interview, which will help us with our research in so many ways.

(A) Background
1. Which country are you from, and how long have you been staying in Korea? Please introduce us about you back in your country.
2. Did you first come to Korea to work as a sex worker? If so, how did you get the advice and information to work? If not, what was your first purpose of the visit? What kind of VISA do you have?

(B) About the work
1. Please tell us about your previous work and what you did as a sex worker. Where and how long did you work?
2. What did you mainly do when you were not working? Could you tell us your daily routine?
3. What were the advantages and disadvantages of your job and working conditions? What would you say about your previous job?
4. Where did you live in Korea, with whom?

(C) Stereotypes
1. Did you tell others about your job? If so, why? If not, why not?
2. Do you think there are stereotypes about sex workers? If yes, what kind of stereotypes and labels do you think people mainly have about sex workers? Please tell us about any situations that happened because of a stereotype about being a sex worker, and tell us how you felt.

(D) After the job
1. How did you get to know this support group helping sex workers? Why did you quit the job?
2. What are your future plans? Are you planning to go back to your country? If so, why? If not, what are you planning to do further on in Korea?

Once again, thank you for your time.

Thursday, September 24, 2015

[Blog Post #1] Introducing our project

[Blog Post #1] Introducing our project

A. Group Members:

Our team members are all students of Seoul National University taking the same Advanced English classes. We have different majors but gathered as a team by our common interests in learning about sex workers in Korea. To introduce our members; Sung Yoon Park majoring in Social Studies Education, Hyejin Woo majoring in Social work and Sohyun Lee majoring in Architecture Engineering.

B. Topic: Stereotypes and labels of foreign sex workers in Korea

This semester (2015 fall), our Advanced English Culture and Society class is studying various subcultures in Korea and some stereotypes or labels that exist along. Of the many groups, our team will particularly focus on foreigner sex workers that work or used to work in Korea. We are interested in this particular subculture because of the lack of public access, owing to the industry being illegal and the negative labels upon the group. We hope that this project will reveal some misunderstood/unknown facts about the group and as well lighten stereotypes that affect the subculture members.


C. Common Stereotypes or Labels we might have:

A common image of a sex worker is a woman who has a nice figure and wears erotic clothing.
Sex workers had unfortunate childhoods. They suffered from poverty, and had no choice but to start working at an early age.
Sex workers probably did not grow up in a supportive family environment, and they may have been victims of domestic violence when they were young.
Sex workers received a low level of education, and cannot get other jobs because of it.
Sex workers are overly conscious of their looks, and probably would have done a plastic surgery.
Sex workers are extravagant. They spend a lot of money on makeup products and luxury clothing. They have no sense of economy, so they don’t save up any money.
Sex workers are ashamed of what they do for their living. They will not continue on with the work if they saved up enough money.
Sex workers cannot start a family. Most of them are not married because they cannot form a healthy relationship with one partner.
Sex workers have venereal diseases. The kind of work they do, and the unsanitary environment that they do it in, generally makes them unhealthy.

D. Our Plan 

We don't know foreign sex workers directly, so we think that we have to contact through foreign sex workers welfare centers. There are some centers in Korea, so we will contact them right after the 'Chu-seok'. We can see several phone numbers in this blog(http://ggholic.tistory.com/625). Because there are foreign counselors also, interviewing in English can be possible. After we make an appointment with one center, we will visit there in 2 weeks. 

E. Preliminary Research

1. Sex Industry in Korea (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5_TDiZ024A)



This video shows why so many girls step in prostitute. The most important reason in the vedio is the financial difficulties. Worst of all some students are doing prostitute for their tuition. There is no a total inspection research in Korea aiming female college women, It is believed that many female students are doing prostitute because of the overpriced tuition. We think things are not much different in foreign sex workers, because most of them come from developing countries such as Vietnam to make money. Furthermore, they would not be fully protected under the law because the prostitute is illegal in itself and a lot of foreign sex workers are illegal aliens. We thought prostitute can not be solved and it is just a their choice on their own initiative so far. However, as you can see in this video, prostitute is not just a personal problem but social problem. We have to handle it as a public agenda especially for foreign sex workers who haven't been considered.

2. Foreigner women prostitutes with fake ID are in full swing again

https://youtu.be/YUF9L80sUB8




This news report is about foreigner women who come to Korea with fake ID and illegal visas to work in the sex industry, and the police's effort to crack down the illegal businesses.

3. Who are they? (by Jason Lim)
(http://koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/opinon/2011/06/137_88538.html) ;To access article #3 in Blog Entry #1 ("Who are they?"), you actually have to cut and paste the link into your browser, as clicking on the posted link will not take you there directly.


This is an opinion column of Korea Times, written by Jason Lim who is a Washington D.C. based political consultant. He is talking about how the sex business agenda in Korea is going in the wrong direction. The government always emphasizes the belief that all sex workers in Korea are held against their will, and forced to work. However the recent massive demonstration by the sex workers themselves made us acutely aware of the fact that they are just ordinary women around us, just taking on a different job. He is not an advocate of a certain political stance regarding prostitution in Korea, but he thinks that the policy debates about this subject must begin by looking at sex workers as individual human beings, not as imaginary creatures.